A Double Life: The Challenge Recordings 1959-1966 Jerry Fuller


Ace Records
Catalogue Id:
CDCHD 1209

Jerry Fuller enjoyed modest hits between 1959 and 1961 with ‘Betty My Angel’, ‘Tennessee Waltz’, ‘Guilty Of Loving You’ and the very Gene Pitneyesque ‘Shy Away’, all prime examples of the kind of records you’d expect to find on one of Ace’s “Teenage Crush” compilations. “A Double Life”, the first ever collection of the Texas-born singer’s recordings cut during his sevenyear tenure at Challenge Records of Los Angeles, includes all four of those, plus a whole lot more.

I say singer, but Jerry Fuller was a man of many talents – he wrote or co-wrote about half of the songs included here and was also pretty hot as a producer. The typical Ace customer might be aware of his name via great songs like ‘Travelin’ Man’ and ‘A Wonder Like You’, which he wrote for his friend Ricky Nelson. Others will be familiar with Gary Puckett’s ‘Young Girl’ and ‘Lady Willpower’, which Jerry also penned, or the Knickerbockers’ quasi-Merseybeat nugget ‘Lies’ and OC Smith’s ‘The Son Of Hickory Holler’s Tramp’, Fuller productions both.

Then, of course, there are the fans of blue-eyed Northern soul and Popcorn who have been lapping up Jerry’s own recordings of ‘I Get Carried Away’, ‘What Happened To The Music’ and the 100 mph Motown-esque stomper ‘Double Life’ for many years. ‘I Dreamed About My Lover’ and ‘Anna From Louisiana’ strike me as prime contenders for the Popcorn scene too. Maybe if Fuller hadn’t been so busy writing for and producing other artists, or if Uncle Sam hadn’t stalled his recording career by calling him up in 1961, he might have stood a chance of becoming LA’s answer to Gene Pitney, for if epics of pop melodrama like ‘Hollywood Star’ are anything to go by, he sure had what it took.

A key record in the story of Challenge Records is the Champs’ ‘Tequila’, which Jerry cut in a vocal version in 1964. In fact, the various members of the Champs play on numerous of the more rocking selections here, so followers of that group need to investigate the collection further. Elsewhere you get ‘The Master Plan’ and ‘Man In Black’, jangling message songs redolent of PF Sloan or Sonny & Cher, plus a healthy shot of clean-cut teen fare, including ‘Above And Beyond’ and ‘One Heart’, duets with Diane Maxwell, a Connie Francis wannabe par excellence.

Other highlights include the Little Anthony-styled ‘I Get Carried Away’, the PJ Proby-penned ‘I Only Came To Dance With You’ and, maybe the classiest track Jerry ever recorded, ‘Turn To Me’, a big beat ballad with a sumptuous production worthy of the Righteous Brothers. The booklet makes for an excellent read too, based upon recent interviews with Jerry Fuller.

By Mick Patrick


Track listing


Side 1

Delivery & Returns


We offer free P&P to UK addresses. For all other territories packaging is free and postage is charged on a weight basis.

We use Royal Mail First Class for UK deliveries and standard Air Mail for all other territories, very large orders will usually be sent via parcelforce. You may cancel your order at any time prior to your order being dispatched by emailing us at orders@acerecords.com ensuring that you quote your name, address and order reference number or by telephoning +44 (0) 208 453 1311 between 9am and 5pm GMT/BST, Monday to Friday. Please note: As music downloads are dispatched immediately after purchase, there is no possibility of cancelling these orders.

In the event that any products supplied to you by us are damaged or defective, we agree to replace or repair the damaged or defective products or refund the amount you paid for such goods (including postage & packaging) providing you notify us (either via post at or e-mail: orders@acerecords.com ) and return the goods within 28 days of purchase. Physical goods should be sent back to us in the same condition you received them to: “Returns” Ace Records, Such Close, Letchworth Garden City SG6 1JF, United Kingdom. Music downloads should be returned to us via the e-mail address above including a copy of your notification.

You have the right to cancel your order within seven days of purchase, or seven days of receipt of the goods (whichever is the longer). If you choose to cancel your order, full payment will be returned to you. Returned items should be sent to: “Returns” c/o Ace Records, Such Close, Letchworth Garden City SG6 1JF, United Kingdom. Music downloads should be returned to us via the email address: orders@acerecords.com including a copy of your notice of cancellation and order number.

Press quotes


An impressive set. ★★★★

Record Collector

Customer reviews


Customers who bought this item also bought